A new paper from the Oxford Internet Institute (OII) at the University of Oxford emphasizes the urgent need for a structured framework to research the impact of artificial intelligence (AI) on the mental health of young people. As children and adolescents increasingly engage with AI-driven platforms via digital devices, the researchers argue that existing approaches to studying the influence of digital technologies on youth wellbeing are inadequate.
Published in The Lancet Child and Adolescent Health on January 21, the paper, titled “From Social Media to Artificial Intelligence: Improving Research on Digital Harms in Youth,” identifies key gaps in current research and stresses the necessity of evolving research methods to address the distinct challenges posed by AI technologies. The authors warn that AI, as an emerging force, risks being analyzed through the same flawed lens that plagued early social media studies—often with inconsistent findings and a lack of comprehensive, long-term research.
The researchers outline four main sections in their analysis:
Review of Recent Research on Digital Technology and Youth Mental Health: The paper reviews existing research on the effects of technology on young people’s mental health, highlighting key limitations such as inconsistent conclusions and a lack of causal studies.
Challenges in Study Design and Interpretation: The authors examine the challenges inherent in the design of studies, especially in interpreting the effects of digital technologies on mental health. These challenges include neglecting contextual factors such as the type of technology use and individual differences among young people.
Proposals for Improving Research Methods: The paper calls for more rigorous methods, focusing on ensuring causal relationships and relevant outcomes for studying AI’s impact on youth mental health.
Collaboration for Better Policy and Practice: The researchers advocate for collaboration between researchers, policymakers, tech companies, caregivers, and young people to create evidence-based policies and practices that protect the mental wellbeing of youth.
Dr. Karen Mansfield, lead author of the paper, explained that the rapid adoption of AI technologies by young people demands a proactive research approach. She emphasized that, like social media, AI presents new challenges that require nuanced and well-coordinated research to understand its effects on mental health. “Young people are already adopting new ways of interacting with AI, and without a solid framework for collaboration between stakeholders, evidence-based policy on AI will lag behind, as it did for social media,” Dr. Mansfield said.
The paper criticizes the simplistic approach to social media research, which often treats it as a single, isolated factor affecting mental health, ignoring the complexities of different usage patterns and contextual variables. The authors suggest that AI research must avoid the same pitfalls and focus on understanding the full spectrum of interactions and outcomes. They argue that without addressing these issues, research could fall into a “new media panic,” similar to the early responses to social media’s effects.
The researchers also note that many social media studies are outdated, with data that frequently exclude vulnerable populations—especially those at higher risk for mental health problems. They propose a shift toward research designs that focus on the most relevant aspects of AI use and prioritize vulnerable groups that need the most attention.
In conclusion, the paper asserts that as young people continue to adopt AI-driven platforms, the gap between research and policy will grow unless urgent changes are made in how we study the issue. By learning from the shortcomings of past research on social media, researchers can help shape policies that regulate AI technologies and protect the mental health of young people as they interact with these platforms.
The authors call for a collaborative, comprehensive approach to research that includes all stakeholders to create better guidelines for understanding the complex relationship between AI and youth mental health.
Related topics:
