Abstract: Circadian disruption, often linked to depression and mood disorders, has been extensively studied in controlled laboratory settings but remains underexplored in real-world contexts. A recent study using wearable data from over 800 first-year medical trainees aims to fill this gap by quantifying the real-world impact of circadian disruption on mental health. Analyzing more than 50,000 days of data, the research identifies significant links between circadian misalignment and mood, both before and after the trainees began shift work. This study offers insights into the potential for wearable technologies to serve as noninvasive tools for monitoring circadian disruption and its effects on mental health, providing a valuable marker for psychiatric intervention.
Introduction: Modern lifestyles, characterized by irregular work hours, shift work, and exposure to artificial light, have introduced significant disruptions to natural circadian rhythms. These disruptions are increasingly recognized as key contributors to the global rise in mental health issues, including mood and anxiety disorders, which affect approximately 20% of the world’s population. Depression and anxiety alone rank among the leading causes of disability and early mortality. Given the complexity of mental health conditions, understanding and predicting risk factors, including circadian disruption, is crucial for early intervention and prevention.
Circadian disruption is typically measured in two main ways: 1) misalignment between internal biological clocks (e.g., central vs. peripheral rhythms) and 2) misalignment between internal rhythms and behavioral rhythms such as the sleep-wake cycle. Previous studies have shown that these disruptions can correlate with mood disorders, with research focusing largely on the alignment between sleep patterns and circadian markers. However, translating these findings from controlled lab environments to real-world settings remains a significant challenge.
Wearable technology, which continuously collects data on sleep patterns, activity levels, and heart rate, offers a promising solution to this issue. Such tools can passively monitor circadian rhythms in real-world environments, providing valuable insights into the relationship between circadian disruption and mental health. This study builds on previous work using wearable devices to assess circadian disruption and its potential links to depressive symptoms.
Methods: In this study, researchers analyzed wearable data from 833 medical interns who wore Fitbit Charge 2 devices for an average of 120.8 days, collecting data on heart rate, activity, and sleep patterns. The participants were monitored before and after starting shift work, offering a unique opportunity to observe the effects of altered work schedules on circadian rhythms. To assess circadian disruption, the study used a state-of-the-art nonlinear filtering approach to calculate three key digital markers:
CRCO-Sleep Misalignment: The phase difference between the central circadian rhythm (CRCO) and the sleep-wake cycle.
CRPO-Sleep Misalignment: The phase difference between the peripheral circadian rhythm (CRPO) and the sleep-wake cycle.
Internal Misalignment: The phase difference between CRCO and CRPO, which measures disruptions in internal biological clocks.
The researchers then explored the relationship between these markers and mood, using data collected from a mobile app that tracked mood and depressive symptoms via the 9-item Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9).
Results: The study found that CRCO-Sleep Misalignment had the most significant impact on mood, particularly the following day. Trainees who experienced greater misalignment between their central circadian rhythm and sleep-wake cycle reported more negative mood states. Conversely, mood disturbances appeared to influence internal misalignment between CRCO and CRPO. This bidirectional relationship underscores the complex interaction between circadian rhythms and mental health.
The analysis also highlighted that CRCO-Sleep Misalignment was strongly associated with specific depressive symptoms, including difficulties with sleep, appetite changes, and overeating. These findings align with previous laboratory-based research linking circadian disruption to depressive symptoms, suggesting that wearables could be a useful tool for identifying individuals at risk.
Additionally, changes in the 9-item Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) scores provided further validation of the circadian disruption markers, confirming that shifts in circadian rhythms are not only measurable but also clinically significant in the context of mental health.
Discussion: This study provides strong evidence for the use of wearable technology to assess circadian disruption and its relationship to mental health. By using large-scale, real-world data, the researchers demonstrate that digital markers of circadian misalignment are not only reliable but also closely linked to mood changes and depressive symptoms in medical trainees. The findings suggest that wearable data could be a valuable tool for early detection of mood disturbances, allowing for more timely interventions.
The bidirectional nature of the relationship between circadian disruption and mood highlights the importance of considering both factors when developing strategies for mental health management. Understanding how circadian rhythms influence mood and vice versa could pave the way for targeted treatments that address both physiological and psychological aspects of mental health.
In particular, the study’s results emphasize the potential of wearable technologies to offer personalized and scalable solutions for monitoring mental health risks. As such, the findings could have significant implications for workplace wellness programs, especially in high-stress environments like healthcare, where shift work is common.
Conclusion: This study provides compelling evidence that digital markers of circadian disruption, derived from wearable data, can serve as reliable indicators of mental health risks. The research not only reinforces the importance of circadian rhythms in mental health but also opens the door for further exploration into how wearable technologies can be utilized for both prevention and intervention in psychiatric care. With mental health conditions on the rise, such noninvasive, real-time monitoring could become a critical tool in mitigating the effects of circadian disruption and improving overall well-being.
Related topics:
